Online Ordering
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Welcome to our Gluttonous Goods!
Right now we have a limited menu and delivery window as we are just starting out. Please note that all cookie orders should be in by Tuesday night so that they can be made fresh and out to you by Friday! If you have special requests on day to accept delivery or want something that isn't on the menu (such as a cake or a certain type of cookie), feel free to email us at thirdcirclebaking@gmail.com and we will do our best to accommodate you and your desires!
Seven Sins-ations
Our specialty treats, so delicious it might just be a sin!
Envy
A double chocolate chip cookie topped with a luscious mint cream and shaved chocolate!
$9.00
Gluttony
A chocolate chip cookie topped with brownie batter and an Oreo. Three desserts in one for our gluttony goodness!
$9.00
Greed
A rich chocolate chip cookie smothered in a layer of caramel and topped with chocolate and gold luster dust.
$9.00
Lust
A red velvet cookie with a decadent white chocolate ganache.
$9.00
Pride
A rainbow sugar cookie with a delightful lavender frosting!
$9.00
Sloth
Too lazy to bake a cookie, this features a cookie dough base and a no-bake cheesecake.
$9.00
Wrath
A spicy chocolate krackolate topped with a spiced cream and candied bacon.
$9.00
Four Pack
Pick four of the Sins to put together for your own custom box of Sins.
$30.00
Set of Seven Sins-ations
One of each of our Seven Sins-ations. Which Sin aligns with your taste buds? Try them all to find out!
$50.00
Naked Cookies
Butter Pecan
Our newest naked cookie, a butter pecan and toffee cookie!
$5.00
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Maybe the best chocolate chip cookies you will ever try!
$5.00
Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter Cookies
Our classic chocolate chip cookie made with a balance of chocolate chips and peanut butter chips.
$5.00
Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
A chocolate cookie filled with both regular and white chocolate chips.
$5.00
Lemon Blueberry Cookies
The perfect blend of two flavors in one delicious cookie.
$5.00
Red Velvet Cookies
A red, chocolate cookie with white chocolate chips!
$5.00
Shortbread
Bite sized buttery goodness! Pack of 18 (3 cookies per serving)
$15.00
Snickerdoodle
A soft, chewy cinnamon and sugar cookie!
$5.00
Sugar Cookies
A soft but thick sugar cookie to delight your taste buds!
$5.00
Mixed Six Pack
Pick any six of our Naked Cookies to mix together into a box of pure deliciousness!
$25.00
Brownies
$5.00
Cupcakes
$8.00
Tantalizing Treats
Mini Key Lime Pies
Personal sized Key Lime Pies, perfect for the Florida summer! Pack of Four
$25.00
Mini Caramel Pretzel Cheesecakes
Personal sized Caramel Cheesecakes on a pretzel base, topped with pretzels and caramel. Pack of Four
$25.00
Cookie Dough Dip
Safe to eat cookie dough dip, paired with chocolate graham crackers.
$6.66